FDIS vs FXD

AFDIS

BFXD

Measures won5–1FDIS wins · of 6 · 5Y

$10,000 · 5Y$12,076FDIS · FXD $11,720

Lowest cost0.08%FDIS · $8 on $10k

Most income0.74%FDIS · $74 on $10k

Smallest drop−13.9%FXD · worst fall in 1Y

Held in common22.7%FDIS and FXD

Fidelity MSCI Consumer Discretionary Index ETF · $1.6BFirst Trust Consumer Discretionary AlphaDEX Fund · $274M

+15.3%3 years · per year$15,335 · $14,607+13.5%

+3.8%5 years · per year$12,076 · $11,720+3.2%

0.08%Expense ratio$8 · $60 on $10k · lower wins0.60%

0.74%12-mo yield$74 · $67 on $10k0.67%

End-of-day Nov 11, 2026 · $10,000 5 years ago, dividends reinvested · ● winner of the row · each row scaled to the bigger of the two

5Y2 funds

#			Trend
1	AFDIS	Fidelity MSCI Consumer Discretionary Index ETFRead Desk		0.08%	0.74%	−0.1%	+3.1%	+3.2%	+15.3%	+3.8%	−15.5%	$1.6B
2	BFXD	First Trust Consumer Discretionary AlphaDEX FundRead Desk		0.60%	0.67%	−0.1%	+5.4%	+9.1%	+13.5%	+3.2%	−13.9%	$274M

End-of-day Nov 11, 2026 · total return, dividends in · 3Y and 5Y per year · A and B = the pair in versus

5Y2 funds

#			Trend
1	AFDIS	Fidelity MSCI Consumer Discretionary Index ETFRead Desk		0.08%	0.74%	−0.1%	+3.1%	+3.2%	+15.3%	+3.8%	−15.5%	$1.6B
2	BFXD	First Trust Consumer Discretionary AlphaDEX FundRead Desk		0.60%	0.67%	−0.1%	+5.4%	+9.1%	+13.5%	+3.2%	−13.9%	$274M

End-of-day Nov 11, 2026 · total return, dividends in · 3Y and 5Y per year · A and B = the pair in versus

Cards for this view

FDIS

Fidelity MSCI Consumer Discretionary Index

$12,076

FXD

First Trust Consumer Discretionary AlphaDEX Fund

$11,720

Loading…